With the Winter Meetings just around the corner, and with the amount of online chatter from some usually reputable sources, it feels like the Cubs are close to a deal or two. That prospect has fans torn trying to decide who should stay and who should go. For a fanbase that cried foul after the North Siders failed to reach the playoffs last year, it’s odd to see so many opposed to a big move or two. I know everybody has their favorite players, but right now the Cubs look like an 85-88 win team on paper and that may not be enough to get to the postseason.
— MLB Trade Rumors (@mlbtraderumors) December 6, 2019
Though the Nationals proved last year that all you need to do is make it to the dance to have a shot at winning the World Series, the Cubs shouldn’t have playoff aspirations that make them prohibitive underdogs if they manage to sneak into the postseason.
The player generating the most pre-Meetings buzz has been Willson Contreras and it’s no wonder. He’s inexpensive, won’t be a free agent until 2022, and is one of the best hitting catchers in baseball. But more than who gets traded, the bigger question is what type of return Theo Epstein is looking for. Certainly the first major move he makes will set the tone for the rest of the winter and next season. An acquisition of prospects could mean the Cubs are going to try to retool or perhaps even rebuild the roster completely. If the president of baseball operations is targeting veterans it may signal his attempt to go all in to get another championship.
I am of the mind that Epstein’s competitive nature dictates that he wants another World Series in the next year or two. The Cardinals don’t look like a true divisional dynasty and it looks like the Brewers are taking a step back. The Reds are trying to improve, but the division is truly up for grabs. Would it be so bad if the Cubs hung onto their core four, traded some of their peripheral redundancy, and made a strong run this year and next?
Cubs News & Notes
- The Tigers are reportedly showing at least some interest in former Cubs shortstop Addison Russell.
- Braves center fielder Ender Inciarte has resurfaced as a player of interest in the Cubs quest to find a center fielder who can bat leadoff.
- The Cubs will need to find a “like-minded team” if they want to trade Contreras (subscription to The Athletic required).
- Jim Bowden of The Athletic suggests that the Cubs trade minor league outfielder Brennen Davis and pitcher Cory Abbott to the Royals for Whit Merrifield ($). I’ll pass on trading Davis, thank you.
- Epstein views the upcoming Winter Meetings as decision time, or, as it’s known in most parts, “time to shit or get off the pot.”
- Finding a replacement for Cole Hamels with limited financial flexibility is one of the goals the front office hopes to achieve next week in San Diego.
- One starter who could be a decent replacement for Hamels is former Braves and Astros pitcher Dallas Keuchel.
- With a +252 run differential, the 2016 Cubs were the best championship team of the decade.
- Ian Happ is primed for a strong 2020 campaign.
- The Cubs, Diamondbacks, and Giants appear to have the most initial interest in free agent outfielder Nicholas Castellanos.
- Meanwhile, the Cubs, Mets, and Diamondbacks all seem to be genuinely interested in trading for Red Sox center fielder Jackie Bradley, Jr.
The Padres have acquired all-purpose outfielder Tommy Pham in a four-player trade with the Rays. Hunter Renfroe, minor league shortstop Xavier Edwards, and an unnamed prospect will be headed to Tampa Bay, according to multiple reports.
The Padres have hired former Cubs and Yankees pitching coach Larry Rothschild.
Though Rule 5 success stories are always great reads, more than a few inexpensive pickups have failed miserably. Lendy Castillo in 2012 was a great example.
Hardball Times: The Many Non-Successes of the Rule 5 Draft https://t.co/PqEW7Lx7VR
— FanGraphs Baseball (@fangraphs) December 6, 2019
They Said It
- “If you look across Major League Baseball, the industry’s kind of accused of hugging their prospects, at times, and holding onto players and caring a lot about prospect rankings and things like that. Not being willing to make deals that might make you look bad. Even if you get the performance you’re looking for, you’re afraid of what you’re going to give up is going to burn you. I don’t think we can be accused of that.” – Theo Epstein
- “I think [our players] have a sense of what’s real and what’s not real. We can’t chase down every rumor. We can’t deny every rumor, because we know it’s going to happen and we just have to live with that. But we’re not going to add fuel to that fire.” – Jed Hoyer, at last month’s Owner’s Meetings.
Friday Walk Up Song
What Became of the Likely Lads by The Libertines. The end of the decade could also mean the end of an era for the Chicago Cubs. See you Sunday with a preview of the Winter Meetings.